20:I[80532,["https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/1s2fk1qiohww4.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/1ykyq0tjtg5pe.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3hmex_cb1t3kl.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/09avfn1e0ica7.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/19smqnel40bj3.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3xo6-h2m3txsp.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/25qi2qzf4193s.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2lkt5gqei_qyz.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/0dh-gcuzjb-s5.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3kj767owr3l2x.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2jo_qx3cuh_qp.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2utjyouv-rab-.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/36k-3k236u26x.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3hurkyjme4q1r.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3-7_u291g0vl1.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3k75tcv2684z2.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/1w07f1tscgpso.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/35hiitja80hpt.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2msopkmn-v204.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3f163oqmqrna9.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/0zg75d6vrr9oy.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/1zsklqhlqkjc9.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3npu85ymaq_6l.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/1p5_v0ahgna_r.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/21u1ha53e9f18.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/0h_c8n_gyrya-.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3h71hfz5dkusp.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/37_2kwln0rkci.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/04ald6z8hw3iv.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2yma_4r8y2mtr.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2_y4q2uwm3dwx.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2lhcdv1d_aw4t.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/14e707kgxt4_n.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3kljlha7jzjcc.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/0bx8fnnqyeh0j.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3uytr1bmjocc6.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/0shv0de36kusq.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/1_776vsoy65cr.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/44o34lugf-l20.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2jfwdvldr2ine.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/12ytt05ct1dhk.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2qkqhul4fqg4t.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/1hz_49kd48jg8.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/0zb2dad98apc5.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/19j-sk9t22_b0.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/318de45sfhkoh.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2277ivz64igcb.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2s75kdey2a4gc.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/0hguu9dlgyy3f.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3q2pkoabxir6e.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/1oneabg2h1n55.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/3o0gf83a_2ud9.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2y1ctufr4j2el.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/1z9uzl7jp8dgt.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/39r36b52l7p_q.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/2hz_mevhilhr6.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/26s_3dx9k2kg8.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/1akd1zuadq633.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/143vsbxpqh8l0.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/095bf44zuyjd-.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/1pvryc76htbar.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/350rgf14x7sgr.js","https://cdn.supademo.com/v3.25.97/_next/static/chunks/39-7a4txtakke.js"],"EmbedViewPage",1] 21:T50b,

22:T84da,

In New Mexico state court, what is required to establish negligence in a wrongful death case in which the defendant is alleging that the fatal act was committed by a contractor or third party outside of the defendant’s control?

Jul 24, 2026, 2:55 PM

Task 2 of 3

Identify New Mexico wrongful-death negligence elements, then test the principal’s liability when the immediate tortfeasor was an independent contractor or third party

Wrongful-death cause of action and negligence elements
Independent-contractor rule and exceptions
Retained control, nondelegable duties, negligent selection, and causation
Allocation of fault and proof burdens

Researching case law: court:(nm OR nmctapp) "independent contractor" "re0.9s

Researching case law: court:(nm OR nmctapp) "nondelegable duty" independ0.4s

Researching case law: court:(nm OR nmctapp) Valdez Cillessen independent0.6s

Researching case law: court:(nm OR nmctapp) Saiz Belen nondelegable duty0.6s

Researching case law: Valdez v. Cillessen & Son1.1s

Researching case law: "Valdez" "Cillessen"1.0s

Researching case law: "Saiz" "Belen School District"0.7s

Researching case law: "independent contractor" "New Mexico" "retained co1.0s

Reviewing a case ×120.4s

Researching case law: "Estate of Saenz" "Ranack" New Mexico Supreme Cour0.7s

Reviewing a case ×30.4s

Looking first for New Mexico Supreme Court authority defining the independent-contractor rule and its exceptions, then for cases applying retained control and nondelegable duty

Valdez v. Cillessen & Son, Inc.

734 P.2d 1258; 105 N.M. 575

New Mexico Supreme Court

Valdez v. Yates Petroleum Corp.

155 P.3d 786; 141 N.M. 381; 2007 NMCA 038

New Mexico Court of Appeals

Sherman v. Cimarex Energy Co.

5 N.M. 480; 2014 NMCA 026

New Mexico Court of Appeals

Lee Lewis Construction, Inc. v. Harrison

70 S.W.3d 778; 2001 WL 1820039

Texas Supreme Court

Woody Investment, LLC v. Sovereign Eagle, LLC

9 N.M. 1; 2015 NMCA 111

New Mexico Court of Appeals

Guide Irys while it works

23:T84d0,

Jul 24, 2026, 2:55 PM

Task 2 of 3

Identify New Mexico wrongful-death negligence elements, then test the principal’s liability when the immediate tortfeasor was an independent contractor or third party

Wrongful-death cause of action and negligence elements
Independent-contractor rule and exceptions
Retained control, nondelegable duties, negligent selection, and causation
Allocation of fault and proof burdens

Researching case law: court:(nm OR nmctapp) "independent contractor" "re0.9s

Researching case law: court:(nm OR nmctapp) "nondelegable duty" independ0.4s

Researching case law: court:(nm OR nmctapp) Valdez Cillessen independent0.6s

Researching case law: court:(nm OR nmctapp) Saiz Belen nondelegable duty0.6s

Researching case law: Valdez v. Cillessen & Son1.1s

Researching case law: "Valdez" "Cillessen"1.0s

Researching case law: "Saiz" "Belen School District"0.7s

Researching case law: "independent contractor" "New Mexico" "retained co1.0s

Reviewing a case ×120.4s

Researching case law: "Estate of Saenz" "Ranack" New Mexico Supreme Cour0.7s

Reviewing a case ×30.4s

Looking first for New Mexico Supreme Court authority defining the independent-contractor rule and its exceptions, then for cases applying retained control and nondelegable duty

Valdez v. Cillessen & Son, Inc.

734 P.2d 1258; 105 N.M. 575

New Mexico Supreme Court

Valdez v. Yates Petroleum Corp.

155 P.3d 786; 141 N.M. 381; 2007 NMCA 038

New Mexico Court of Appeals

Sherman v. Cimarex Energy Co.

5 N.M. 480; 2014 NMCA 026

New Mexico Court of Appeals

Lee Lewis Construction, Inc. v. Harrison

70 S.W.3d 778; 2001 WL 1820039

Texas Supreme Court

Woody Investment, LLC v. Sovereign Eagle, LLC

9 N.M. 1; 2015 NMCA 111

New Mexico Court of Appeals

Guide Irys while it works

24:Ta18,

25:T693,

26:T110b4,

Jul 24, 2026, 2:55 PM

Short Answer

The plaintiff must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the defendant had an independent legal responsibility for the death. It is not enough merely to prove that the contractor or third party acted negligently.

New Mexico’s Wrongful Death Act preserves the tort claim the decedent could have maintained had death not occurred. N.M. Stat. Ann. § 41-2-1 (Section 41-2-1: Death by wrongful act or neglect; liability in damages.). The action must be brought by the decedent’s personal representative. N.M. Stat. Ann. § 41-2-3 (Section 41-2-3: Personal representative to bring action; damages; distribution of proceeds).

Elements Against the Defendant

The plaintiff must establish:

Duty: The defendant owed the decedent a legally recognized duty.
Breach: The defendant failed to exercise the required degree of care.
Factual causation: But for the defendant’s breach, the death would not have occurred.
Proximate or scope-of-liability causation: The death resulted from the risk that made the defendant’s conduct negligent.
Damages: The breach caused the decedent’s death and recoverable wrongful-death damages.

See Sherman v. Cimarex Energy Co., 2014-NMCA-026, ¶ 9 (2014-NMCA-026).

The contractor’s involvement does not automatically eliminate these elements, but the plaintiff must connect the defendant itself to the fatal occurrence through one or more recognized theories.

Potential Bases for Defendant Liability

1. Agency or Vicarious Liability

The plaintiff may establish that the supposed contractor was actually the defendant’s agent or employee. The decisive issue is generally the defendant’s right to control the method and manner of the work, not the terminology used in the contract.

Relevant evidence includes whether the defendant:

Directed how and when the work was performed;
Controlled operative details;
Assigned tasks to the contractor’s personnel;
Had authority to discipline or remove workers; or
Exercised day-to-day supervision inconsistent with independent-contractor status.

If the contractor genuinely remained free to perform the work in its own manner, the defendant ordinarily is not vicariously liable. Valdez v. Cillessen & Son, Inc., 105 N.M. 575, 579–80, 734 P.2d 1258, 1262–63 (1987) (734 P.2d 1258).

2. Retained-Control Liability

Even if the contractor was independent, the defendant can be directly liable if it retained control over a relevant part of the work and negligently exercised—or failed to exercise—that control.

The plaintiff must prove:

The defendant retained supervisory control over the work connected to the death;
The retained control was sufficiently substantial that the contractor was not entirely free to perform that work in its own way;
The defendant failed to exercise that control reasonably; and
That failure caused the death.

A general right to:

Stop or resume work;
Inspect progress;
Receive reports;
Make nonbinding suggestions; or
Require compliance with general specifications

ordinarily is insufficient. Sherman, 2014-NMCA-026, ¶¶ 9–20 (2014-NMCA-026). Where the evidence concerning retained control is disputed, the predicate control question ordinarily belongs to the factfinder. Lopez v. Devon Energy Production Co., 2020-NMCA-033, ¶¶ 35–37, 468 P.3d 887 (2020-NMCA-033).

3. Defendant’s Own Direct Negligence

Lack of operational control does not foreclose liability for the defendant’s own conduct. Potential theories include:

Negligent selection or retention of an incompetent contractor;
Negligent instructions supplied to the contractor;
Negligent coordination among multiple contractors;
Failure to disclose hazards known to the defendant;
Creation of a dangerous condition;
Premises liability, if the defendant owned or possessed the site; or
Violation of a statute or regulation imposing a duty directly upon the defendant.

For negligent selection or retention, the plaintiff generally must show that the defendant failed to use reasonable care in selecting or continuing to employ a competent contractor, and that the contractor’s relevant incompetence caused the death. Lopez, 2020-NMCA-033, ¶¶ 32–34 (2020-NMCA-033).

4. Nondelegable Duty

A defendant cannot escape a genuinely nondelegable duty merely by assigning the work to an independent contractor. New Mexico recognizes such duties where:

The duty arises from a special relationship toward the public or the particular plaintiff;
A statute or regulation places the safeguarding obligation on the defendant; or
The work involves a peculiar or inherently dangerous risk requiring special precautions.

For inherently dangerous work, the risk must be unusual and must create a strong probability of harm if special precautions are not taken. The court determines whether the duty is nondelegable; the factfinder ordinarily determines:

What precautions were reasonably necessary;
Whether those precautions were absent; and
Whether their absence proximately caused the death.

Saiz ex rel. Estate of Saiz v. Belen School District, 113 N.M. 387, 393–97, 827 P.2d 102, 108–12 (1992) (827 P.2d 102).

This doctrine is narrower where the decedent was an employee of the independent contractor rather than an uninvolved member of the public. The decedent’s status therefore matters.

Effect of the Third-Party-Fault Defense

New Mexico generally applies several liability. If the defendant establishes that another person’s fault proximately caused the death, the defendant ordinarily is responsible only for its own allocated percentage of damages. N.M. Stat. Ann. § 41-3A-1(B) (Section 41-3A-1: Several liability).

Accordingly:

The plaintiff bears the burden of proving the defendant’s duty, breach, causation, and damages.
The defendant, when seeking allocation to a contractor or nonparty, bears the burden of establishing that person’s fault and its causal contribution.
The contractor’s negligence does not exonerate the defendant if the defendant’s own breach was also a proximate cause.
If the contractor’s conduct was the sole proximate cause and no agency, retained-control, direct-negligence, premises, statutory, or nondelegable-duty theory applies, the defendant should not be liable.
Joint and several liability may still apply where the relationship creates vicarious liability or where a recognized nondelegable-duty/public-policy exception applies. N.M. Stat. Ann. § 41-3A-1(C) (Section 41-3A-1: Several liability); Saiz, 113 N.M. at 398–99, 827 P.2d at 113–14 (827 P.2d 102).

Practical Proof Required

To withstand summary judgment, the plaintiff should identify admissible evidence establishing at least one concrete link between the defendant and the death, such as:

Contractual control provisions;
Evidence of actual supervision or instructions;
Site-control and premises evidence;
Safety manuals and mandatory procedures;
Prior incidents or notice of the hazard;
Contractor licensing, competence, or safety history;
Applicable statutory or regulatory safeguards; and
Expert evidence connecting the defendant’s breach to the fatal mechanism.

The central inquiry is therefore not simply who physically committed the fatal act, but whether the defendant had an independent legal responsibility concerning the risk that produced the death.

Jul 24, 2026, 2:56 PM

regenerate

Sep 29, 2026, 2:22 AM

New Mexico Standard

A wrongful-death plaintiff must establish that the defendant would have been liable to the decedent had death not occurred. N.M. Stat. Ann. § 41-2-1. The plaintiff must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence:

The defendant owed the decedent a legal duty.
The defendant breached that duty.
The breach was a factual and proximate cause of the death.
The death caused legally recoverable damages.

The contractor’s involvement does not itself defeat the claim. The plaintiff must, however, establish a legally sufficient connection between the defendant and the fatal occurrence.

Potential Bases for Liability

1. Defendant’s Direct Negligence

Control over the person who committed the fatal act is not required when liability rests on the defendant’s own conduct. Potential theories include:

Negligent selection or retention of an incompetent contractor;
Negligent instructions or coordination;
Creation of a dangerous condition;
Failure to disclose a known hazard;
Premises liability;
Failure to implement promised safety measures; or
Violation of a statute or regulation imposing a duty directly on the defendant.

In Lopez v. Devon Energy Production Co., the New Mexico Court of Appeals held that premises liability and negligent selection or retention arise from the defendant’s own duty of reasonable care. The presence of an independent contractor may affect breach and causation, but does not automatically eliminate the duty. 2020-NMCA-033, ¶¶ 25–34, 468 P.3d 887.

2. Retained-Control Liability

A party hiring an independent contractor may be liable if it retained control over the relevant work and failed to exercise that control reasonably.

The plaintiff must prove:

The defendant retained supervisory or operational control over at least part of the work;
The retained control concerned the work or hazard that caused the death;
The defendant exercised, or failed to exercise, that control negligently; and
The negligent exercise of control caused the death.

A general right to inspect progress, receive reports, stop work, make nonbinding suggestions, or require compliance with general specifications ordinarily is insufficient. The retained authority must leave the contractor less than entirely free to perform the relevant work in its own manner. Sherman v. Cimarex Energy Co., 2014-NMCA-026, ¶¶ 8–20.

Disputed evidence about retained control commonly presents a fact question. Relevant evidence includes the contract, mandatory safety policies, actual instructions, supervision, work sequencing, authority to remove personnel, and control over operative details.

3. Agency or Employee Status

The defendant may be vicariously liable if the supposed contractor was actually its agent or employee. The principal consideration is the defendant’s right to control the manner and method of the work.

Evidence that the defendant assigned tasks, directed operative details, controlled schedules, disciplined personnel, or dictated how the work must be performed can support this theory. Valdez v. Cillessen & Son, Inc., 1987-NMSC-015, ¶¶ 20–27, 105 N.M. 575, 734 P.2d 1258.

4. Nondelegable Duty

A defendant cannot avoid a nondelegable duty by assigning performance to an independent contractor. Such a duty may arise from:

A statute or regulation requiring the defendant to provide specified safeguards;
A special relationship with the decedent or public; or
Work presenting a peculiar or inherently dangerous risk.

For inherently dangerous work, the risk must be unusual and create a strong probability of harm unless special precautions are taken. The court determines whether the duty exists. The factfinder generally determines what precautions were necessary, whether they were absent, and whether that absence caused the death. Saiz ex rel. Estate of Saiz v. Belen School District, 1992-NMSC-018, 113 N.M. 387, 827 P.2d 102.

This doctrine has an important limitation. When the decedent was an employee of the independent contractor, New Mexico authority generally does not treat that employee as a protected “third person” under the inherently-dangerous-work exceptions in Restatement Sections 413, 416, and 427. Valdez, ¶¶ 28–29. Retained control, premises liability, negligent selection, or another direct-negligence theory may nevertheless remain available.

Causation and Third-Party Fault

The plaintiff need not prove that the defendant’s negligence was the only cause. The plaintiff must prove that the defendant’s breach contributed legally and factually to the death. The contractor’s conduct may constitute concurrent fault rather than a superseding cause.

If the defendant proves that the contractor or another person was also at fault and proximately caused the death, New Mexico’s several-liability statute ordinarily limits the defendant to its allocated percentage of damages. N.M. Stat. Ann. § 41-3A-1(B). Vicarious-liability and recognized public-policy exceptions remain subject to joint-and-several treatment. Id. § 41-3A-1(C).

Accordingly:

The plaintiff bears the burden of proving the defendant’s duty, breach, causation, and damages.
The defendant bears the statutory burden when seeking allocation based on another person’s fault.
If the third party’s conduct was the sole proximate cause, and no direct, vicarious, retained-control, premises, statutory, or nondelegable-duty theory applies, the defendant is not liable.
A bare assertion that the actor was “outside the defendant’s control” is insufficient if evidence supports an independent duty and breach by the defendant.

References

[R1] N.M. Stat. Ann. § 41-2-1.
[R2] Lopez v. Devon Energy Production Co., 2020-NMCA-033, 468 P.3d 887.
[R3] Sherman v. Cimarex Energy Co., 2014-NMCA-026.
[R4] Valdez v. Cillessen & Son, Inc., 1987-NMSC-015, 105 N.M. 575.
[R5] Saiz ex rel. Estate of Saiz v. Belen School District, 1992-NMSC-018, 113 N.M. 387.
[R6] N.M. Stat. Ann. § 41-3A-1.

Sep 29, 2026, 2:22 AM

27:T5a1,

In , the New Mexico Court of Appeals held that premises liability and negligent selection or retention arise from the defendant’s own duty of reasonable care. The presence of an independent contractor may affect breach and causation, but does not automatically eliminate the duty. 2020-NMCA-033, ¶¶ 25–34, 468 P.3d 887.

28:T570,

29:Tce1,

Sources & Citations

41 citations from 37 sources

2a:T54c,

10:["$","$L20",null,{"demo":{"id":"cmryqisu358m5qmblk0l574u5","createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:25:30.363Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:59.429Z","title":"Research with Thorough Mode","published":true,"color":"#6487d7","authorId":"cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y","metadesc":"Ask a legal question in Thorough mode and get a cited analysis you can check and export. Workbench plans the research, shows each step as it runs, and links every authority behind the answer.","customMetadataImage":null,"ctabtntext":"Explore Irys","ctabtncolor":"#6487d7","ctabtntextcolor":"#ffffff","ctabtnlink":"https://core.iqidis.ai/?utm_source=supademo&utm_medium=demo","autoplay":true,"autoplayduration":2000,"autoPlayDelay":1000,"customizePerStep":false,"showplaypause":true,"loop":false,"progressbar":true,"showPlayBar":true,"font":"Custom","workspaceId":"cmpe00nv501sp2n0j6qwe7jzg","darkmode":false,"shared":true,"folderId":null,"border":true,"nextButton":true,"showSteps":false,"globalSettings":true,"hotspotTextVisible":true,"hotspotAnimationVisible":false,"hotspotOpacity":50,"number":null,"topBar":true,"indexable":true,"displayAuthor":false,"displayDescription":false,"showSupademoLink":true,"showReplayButton":true,"showFullscreenButton":true,"showCCButton":true,"disableKeyboardNavigation":false,"captionsPosition":"Bottom","archived":false,"archivedAt":null,"domainURL":"https://workbench.irys.ai/","brandLogo":"https://media.supademo.com/workspaces/cmpe00nv501sp2n0j6qwe7jzg/DBcO-xDAfXhLp7d0PINZe.png","allowDuplicate":false,"recordOwnVoice":false,"backgroundId":null,"backgroundMusicUrl":null,"backgroundMusicVolume":50,"demoSource":"Extension","type":"Default","fullWidth":false,"detectBrowserLanguage":true,"sourceLanguage":"English","customFontId":"ckbjw1Gxvga_ghFxUse5z","mobileHotspotView":true,"config":null,"showWatermark":null,"watermarkLogoUrl":null,"watermarkText":null,"watermarkLink":null,"sendNotification":true,"allowExternalComments":false,"currentPublishedVersion":null,"hasUnpublishedChanges":true,"author":{"id":"cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y","name":"Krushab Mistry","image":"https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/a/ACg8ocI2Sg9Fh3jZroJiSlUFC5-IfilAyfrdYaeXpA_DTNJd-bf5VA=s96-c"},"steps":[{"id":"cmryqrbc558xpqmblijsf670i","number":1,"text":null,"image":null,"video":null,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:32:07.590Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:45.498Z","demoId":"cmryqisu358m5qmblk0l574u5","imageWidth":"688","imageHeight":"0","mouseXCooridnate":"0","mouseYCooridnate":"0","editedImage":null,"widthOrg":2940,"heightOrg":1662,"bgcolor":"#4f46e5","textcolor":"#fff","imgState":null,"trimStart":0,"trimEnd":100,"videoWidth":null,"videoHeight":null,"videoDuration":null,"videoProjectId":null,"audio":null,"audioText":null,"voice":null,"audioLanguage":null,"audioDuration":null,"captionsUrl":null,"zoomPositionX":null,"zoomPositionY":null,"zoomWidth":null,"zoomHeight":null,"playbackRate":1,"mute":null,"mediaFitMode":"Cover","mediaAlignMode":"Top","htmlCaptureId":null,"backdrop":"None","pageUrl":null,"recordingSessionId":null,"preventScroll":false,"scrollTopOverride":null,"scrollOverrides":null,"duration":null,"transition":null,"customDescription":null,"hotspots":[],"chapter":{"id":"cmryqrbcd58xrqmbll33qwui2","stepId":"cmryqrbc558xpqmblijsf670i","enabled":true,"type":"Link","skip":false,"heading":"Research with Thorough Mode","description":"

Ask a legal question and get a cited analysis you can check and export. Runs take a few minutes. About 50 seconds.

","headingColor":"#272727","descriptionColor":"#272727","theme":"Light","blurIntensity":24,"embedCode":null,"layout":"Left","coverImageType":"STEP","coverImageSource":null,"logoEnabled":true,"logoSource":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/screenshots/dATFgIaTIf5xkWbIlQB_J.png","logoAltText":null,"emailValidationMode":"CompanyEmail","phoneValidationEnabled":false,"labelledFormEnabled":false,"buttons":[{"id":"cmryqrbcp58xuqmblgzjg4kgc","createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:32:07.610Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-23T06:40:31.071Z","chapterId":"cmryqrbcd58xrqmbll33qwui2","content":"See it in action","btnColor":"#6487d7","color":"#ffffff","linkTxt":"cmryqiz5j58m7qmblw4irj1gs","isLinkExternal":false,"openInNewTab":true,"animation":"Ripple","order":0,"isBold":true,"isItalic":false}],"backgroundId":null,"background":null,"formFields":[]},"videoProject":null},{"id":"cmryqj51458mdqmbliagk6u95","number":2,"text":null,"image":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/UarYJjPh2ZI2Tyj6CXPwP.jpg","video":null,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:25:46.168Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:45.498Z","demoId":"cmryqisu358m5qmblk0l574u5","imageWidth":"688","imageHeight":"0","mouseXCooridnate":"52.04081632653062","mouseYCooridnate":"40.312876052948255","editedImage":null,"widthOrg":2940,"heightOrg":1662,"bgcolor":"#4f46e5","textcolor":"#fff","imgState":null,"trimStart":0,"trimEnd":100,"videoWidth":null,"videoHeight":null,"videoDuration":null,"videoProjectId":null,"audio":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/audio/j-xpPqvriMlH5z6Quc_h-.mp3","audioText":"Open the mode menu and pick Thorough.","voice":"FPQ1Odtu8U6Edy2qyGcI","audioLanguage":null,"audioDuration":2.168163265306122,"captionsUrl":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/captions/j-xpPqvriMlH5z6Quc_h-.vtt","zoomPositionX":null,"zoomPositionY":null,"zoomWidth":null,"zoomHeight":null,"playbackRate":1,"mute":null,"mediaFitMode":"Cover","mediaAlignMode":"Top","htmlCaptureId":null,"backdrop":"None","pageUrl":"https://workbench.irys.ai/","recordingSessionId":null,"preventScroll":false,"scrollTopOverride":null,"scrollOverrides":null,"duration":null,"transition":null,"customDescription":null,"hotspots":[{"id":"cmryqj51458meqmbl268axqje","number":2,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:25:46.168Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T20:58:25.318Z","default":true,"text":"Open the mode menu and pick Thorough.","bgcolor":"#6487d7","textcolor":"#ffffff","mouseXCooridnate":"52.04081632653062","mouseYCooridnate":"40.312876052948255","style":"Area","animation":"Pulse","isVisible":true,"boxWidth":4.829931972789116,"boxHeight":3.610108303249097,"prevslide":null,"nextslide":null,"stepId":"cmryqj51458mdqmbliagk6u95","tipposition":"bottom","nextButton":true,"textVisible":true,"htmlValue":"

","aiText":null,"aiTextVisible":false,"anchorNodeId":null,"anchorPosition":"BottomCenter","nextButtonText":"Next","backButtonText":"Prev","hotspotWidth":"Medium","textAlign":"Left","modalPosition":"Center","borderRadius":"Round","nextButtonAction":"Slide","nextButtonUrl":null,"nextButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","nextButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","nextButtonDisabled":false,"backButtonAction":"Slide","backButtonUrl":null,"backButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","backButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","backButtonDisabled":false,"timelineElementId":null}],"chapter":null,"videoProject":null},{"id":"cmryqjcyx58n2qmbl1xvaxb5k","number":3,"text":null,"image":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/I14SEJrRWKJGo_5XF2NMw.jpg","video":null,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:25:56.457Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:45.498Z","demoId":"cmryqisu358m5qmblk0l574u5","imageWidth":"688","imageHeight":"0","mouseXCooridnate":"87.78911564625851","mouseYCooridnate":"42.900120336943445","editedImage":null,"widthOrg":2940,"heightOrg":1662,"bgcolor":"#4f46e5","textcolor":"#fff","imgState":null,"trimStart":0,"trimEnd":100,"videoWidth":null,"videoHeight":null,"videoDuration":null,"videoProjectId":null,"audio":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/audio/CrW-yk62x1uVP84HiXMsG.mp3","audioText":"Ask your question with the facts and jurisdiction, then Send. Workbench plans the research and shows each step as it works.","voice":"FPQ1Odtu8U6Edy2qyGcI","audioLanguage":null,"audioDuration":8.25469387755102,"captionsUrl":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/captions/CrW-yk62x1uVP84HiXMsG.vtt","zoomPositionX":null,"zoomPositionY":null,"zoomWidth":null,"zoomHeight":null,"playbackRate":1,"mute":null,"mediaFitMode":"Cover","mediaAlignMode":"Top","htmlCaptureId":null,"backdrop":"None","pageUrl":"https://workbench.irys.ai/","recordingSessionId":null,"preventScroll":false,"scrollTopOverride":null,"scrollOverrides":null,"duration":null,"transition":null,"customDescription":null,"hotspots":[{"id":"cmryqjcyx58n3qmbl363yp7tr","number":3,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:25:56.457Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T20:58:25.318Z","default":true,"text":"Ask your question with the facts and jurisdiction, then Send. Workbench plans the research and shows each step as it works.","bgcolor":"#6487d7","textcolor":"#ffffff","mouseXCooridnate":"87.78911564625851","mouseYCooridnate":"42.900120336943445","style":"Circle","animation":"Ping","isVisible":true,"boxWidth":null,"boxHeight":null,"prevslide":null,"nextslide":null,"stepId":"cmryqjcyx58n2qmbl1xvaxb5k","tipposition":"left","nextButton":true,"textVisible":true,"htmlValue":"$21","aiText":null,"aiTextVisible":false,"anchorNodeId":null,"anchorPosition":"BottomCenter","nextButtonText":"Next","backButtonText":"Prev","hotspotWidth":"Medium","textAlign":"Left","modalPosition":"Center","borderRadius":"Round","nextButtonAction":"Slide","nextButtonUrl":null,"nextButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","nextButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","nextButtonDisabled":false,"backButtonAction":"Slide","backButtonUrl":null,"backButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","backButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","backButtonDisabled":false,"timelineElementId":null}],"chapter":null,"videoProject":null},{"id":"cmryqluxi58pvqmblrbj4y8hg","number":4,"text":null,"image":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/tLvxJk2_36gTxHgmlrxLu.jpg","video":null,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:27:53.046Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:45.498Z","demoId":"cmryqisu358m5qmblk0l574u5","imageWidth":"688","imageHeight":"0","mouseXCooridnate":"95.1360544217687","mouseYCooridnate":"56.19735258724429","editedImage":null,"widthOrg":2940,"heightOrg":1662,"bgcolor":"#4f46e5","textcolor":"#fff","imgState":null,"trimStart":0,"trimEnd":100,"videoWidth":null,"videoHeight":null,"videoDuration":null,"videoProjectId":null,"audio":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/audio/l0zjK3Vht0QPRzrsJMLzW.mp3","audioText":"Expand a step to see what it's checking.","voice":"FPQ1Odtu8U6Edy2qyGcI","audioLanguage":null,"audioDuration":2.115918367346939,"captionsUrl":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/captions/l0zjK3Vht0QPRzrsJMLzW.vtt","zoomPositionX":null,"zoomPositionY":null,"zoomWidth":null,"zoomHeight":null,"playbackRate":1,"mute":null,"mediaFitMode":"Cover","mediaAlignMode":"Top","htmlCaptureId":null,"backdrop":"None","pageUrl":"https://workbench.irys.ai/chat/cea66a5b-3f43-42f7-bb1b-f6839ae53e84","recordingSessionId":null,"preventScroll":false,"scrollTopOverride":null,"scrollOverrides":null,"duration":null,"transition":null,"customDescription":null,"hotspots":[{"id":"cmryqluxj58pwqmbljoprdm7a","number":4,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:27:53.046Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T20:58:25.318Z","default":true,"text":"Expand a step to see what it's checking.","bgcolor":"#6487d7","textcolor":"#ffffff","mouseXCooridnate":"95.1360544217687","mouseYCooridnate":"56.19735258724429","style":"Circle","animation":"Ping","isVisible":true,"boxWidth":null,"boxHeight":null,"prevslide":null,"nextslide":null,"stepId":"cmryqluxi58pvqmblrbj4y8hg","tipposition":"left","nextButton":true,"textVisible":true,"htmlValue":"$22","aiText":null,"aiTextVisible":false,"anchorNodeId":null,"anchorPosition":"BottomCenter","nextButtonText":"Next","backButtonText":"Prev","hotspotWidth":"Medium","textAlign":"Left","modalPosition":"Center","borderRadius":"Round","nextButtonAction":"Slide","nextButtonUrl":null,"nextButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","nextButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","nextButtonDisabled":false,"backButtonAction":"Slide","backButtonUrl":null,"backButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","backButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","backButtonDisabled":false,"timelineElementId":null}],"chapter":null,"videoProject":null},{"id":"cmryqly7p58pyqmblxw79kd9w","number":5,"text":null,"image":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/xECBlBdXhmvtITKwTzfju.jpg","video":null,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:27:57.301Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:45.498Z","demoId":"cmryqisu358m5qmblk0l574u5","imageWidth":"688","imageHeight":"0","mouseXCooridnate":"94.08163265306122","mouseYCooridnate":"56.19735258724429","editedImage":null,"widthOrg":2940,"heightOrg":1662,"bgcolor":"#4f46e5","textcolor":"#fff","imgState":null,"trimStart":0,"trimEnd":100,"videoWidth":null,"videoHeight":null,"videoDuration":null,"videoProjectId":null,"audio":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/audio/QKDSFYoBs54J45ygAkNRm.mp3","audioText":"Each task lists the authorities it pulled as it goes.","voice":"FPQ1Odtu8U6Edy2qyGcI","audioLanguage":null,"audioDuration":3.186938775510204,"captionsUrl":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/captions/QKDSFYoBs54J45ygAkNRm.vtt","zoomPositionX":null,"zoomPositionY":null,"zoomWidth":null,"zoomHeight":null,"playbackRate":1,"mute":null,"mediaFitMode":"Cover","mediaAlignMode":"Top","htmlCaptureId":null,"backdrop":"None","pageUrl":"https://workbench.irys.ai/chat/cea66a5b-3f43-42f7-bb1b-f6839ae53e84","recordingSessionId":null,"preventScroll":false,"scrollTopOverride":null,"scrollOverrides":null,"duration":null,"transition":null,"customDescription":null,"hotspots":[{"id":"cmryqly7p58pzqmbl7pdlxik0","number":5,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:27:57.301Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T20:58:25.318Z","default":true,"text":"Each task lists the authorities it pulled as it goes.","bgcolor":"#6487d7","textcolor":"#ffffff","mouseXCooridnate":"94.08163265306122","mouseYCooridnate":"56.19735258724429","style":"Circle","animation":"Ping","isVisible":true,"boxWidth":null,"boxHeight":null,"prevslide":null,"nextslide":null,"stepId":"cmryqly7p58pyqmblxw79kd9w","tipposition":"left","nextButton":true,"textVisible":true,"htmlValue":"$23","aiText":null,"aiTextVisible":false,"anchorNodeId":null,"anchorPosition":"BottomCenter","nextButtonText":"Next","backButtonText":"Prev","hotspotWidth":"Medium","textAlign":"Left","modalPosition":"Center","borderRadius":"Round","nextButtonAction":"Slide","nextButtonUrl":null,"nextButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","nextButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","nextButtonDisabled":false,"backButtonAction":"Slide","backButtonUrl":null,"backButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","backButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","backButtonDisabled":false,"timelineElementId":null}],"chapter":null,"videoProject":null},{"id":"cmryqoil358qrqmblkacgfgmh","number":6,"text":null,"image":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/_wcDXVZoKmOy2n5-7In8z.jpg","video":null,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:29:57.015Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:45.498Z","demoId":"cmryqisu358m5qmblk0l574u5","imageWidth":"688","imageHeight":"0","mouseXCooridnate":"60.8843537414966","mouseYCooridnate":"21.780986762936223","editedImage":null,"widthOrg":2940,"heightOrg":1662,"bgcolor":"#4f46e5","textcolor":"#fff","imgState":null,"trimStart":0,"trimEnd":100,"videoWidth":null,"videoHeight":null,"videoDuration":null,"videoProjectId":null,"audio":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/audio/kExUnO-P0h4ktEGeufCOA.mp3","audioText":"Reasoning complete shows every task it ran.","voice":"FPQ1Odtu8U6Edy2qyGcI","audioLanguage":null,"audioDuration":2.742857142857143,"captionsUrl":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/captions/kExUnO-P0h4ktEGeufCOA.vtt","zoomPositionX":null,"zoomPositionY":null,"zoomWidth":null,"zoomHeight":null,"playbackRate":1,"mute":null,"mediaFitMode":"Cover","mediaAlignMode":"Top","htmlCaptureId":null,"backdrop":"None","pageUrl":"https://workbench.irys.ai/chat/cea66a5b-3f43-42f7-bb1b-f6839ae53e84","recordingSessionId":null,"preventScroll":false,"scrollTopOverride":null,"scrollOverrides":null,"duration":null,"transition":null,"customDescription":null,"hotspots":[{"id":"cmryqoil358qsqmblv5eakzi8","number":6,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:29:57.015Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T20:58:25.318Z","default":true,"text":"Reasoning complete shows every task it ran.","bgcolor":"#6487d7","textcolor":"#ffffff","mouseXCooridnate":"60.8843537414966","mouseYCooridnate":"21.780986762936223","style":"Area","animation":"Pulse","isVisible":true,"boxWidth":57.55102040816327,"boxHeight":8.42358604091456,"prevslide":null,"nextslide":null,"stepId":"cmryqoil358qrqmblkacgfgmh","tipposition":"left","nextButton":true,"textVisible":true,"htmlValue":"$24","aiText":null,"aiTextVisible":false,"anchorNodeId":null,"anchorPosition":"BottomCenter","nextButtonText":"Next","backButtonText":"Prev","hotspotWidth":"Medium","textAlign":"Left","modalPosition":"Center","borderRadius":"Round","nextButtonAction":"Slide","nextButtonUrl":null,"nextButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","nextButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","nextButtonDisabled":false,"backButtonAction":"Slide","backButtonUrl":null,"backButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","backButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","backButtonDisabled":false,"timelineElementId":null}],"chapter":null,"videoProject":null},{"id":"cmryqolz658raqmbl7yi3zivs","number":7,"text":null,"image":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/GhKerqxyT_kjznd7LfIqY.jpg","video":null,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:30:01.410Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:45.498Z","demoId":"cmryqisu358m5qmblk0l574u5","imageWidth":"688","imageHeight":"0","mouseXCooridnate":"62.10884353741497","mouseYCooridnate":"34.5367027677497","editedImage":null,"widthOrg":2940,"heightOrg":1662,"bgcolor":"#4f46e5","textcolor":"#fff","imgState":null,"trimStart":0,"trimEnd":100,"videoWidth":null,"videoHeight":null,"videoDuration":null,"videoProjectId":null,"audio":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/audio/5gwTlxKtnd5_TwQWhQPTG.mp3","audioText":"Expand any task to see the research behind it.","voice":"FPQ1Odtu8U6Edy2qyGcI","audioLanguage":null,"audioDuration":2.638367346938776,"captionsUrl":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/captions/5gwTlxKtnd5_TwQWhQPTG.vtt","zoomPositionX":null,"zoomPositionY":null,"zoomWidth":null,"zoomHeight":null,"playbackRate":1,"mute":null,"mediaFitMode":"Cover","mediaAlignMode":"Top","htmlCaptureId":null,"backdrop":"None","pageUrl":"https://workbench.irys.ai/chat/cea66a5b-3f43-42f7-bb1b-f6839ae53e84","recordingSessionId":null,"preventScroll":false,"scrollTopOverride":null,"scrollOverrides":null,"duration":null,"transition":null,"customDescription":null,"hotspots":[{"id":"cmryqolz658rbqmbl0hfh540w","number":7,"createdAt":"2026-07-24T09:30:01.410Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T20:58:25.318Z","default":true,"text":"Expand any task to see the research behind it.","bgcolor":"#6487d7","textcolor":"#ffffff","mouseXCooridnate":"62.10884353741497","mouseYCooridnate":"34.5367027677497","style":"Area","animation":"Pulse","isVisible":true,"boxWidth":52.92517006802721,"boxHeight":2.527075812274368,"prevslide":null,"nextslide":null,"stepId":"cmryqolz658raqmbl7yi3zivs","tipposition":"left","nextButton":true,"textVisible":true,"htmlValue":"$25","aiText":null,"aiTextVisible":false,"anchorNodeId":null,"anchorPosition":"BottomCenter","nextButtonText":"Next","backButtonText":"Prev","hotspotWidth":"Medium","textAlign":"Left","modalPosition":"Center","borderRadius":"Round","nextButtonAction":"Slide","nextButtonUrl":null,"nextButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","nextButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","nextButtonDisabled":false,"backButtonAction":"Slide","backButtonUrl":null,"backButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","backButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","backButtonDisabled":false,"timelineElementId":null}],"chapter":null,"videoProject":null},{"id":"cmulqa7ib028kqmfhgb7s0p7z","number":8,"text":null,"image":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/oAXaZTHsq7RkJd2yUncOI.jpg","video":null,"createdAt":"2026-09-28T20:56:56.195Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:59.323Z","demoId":"cmryqisu358m5qmblk0l574u5","imageWidth":"688","imageHeight":"0","mouseXCooridnate":"31.768707482993197","mouseYCooridnate":"32.190132370637784","editedImage":null,"widthOrg":2940,"heightOrg":1662,"bgcolor":"#4f46e5","textcolor":"#fff","imgState":null,"trimStart":0,"trimEnd":100,"videoWidth":null,"videoHeight":null,"videoDuration":null,"videoProjectId":null,"audio":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/audio/bAXB8ee4WGLlEIKZN7ORt.mp3","audioText":"The answer sets out the rules and the cases that apply.","voice":"FPQ1Odtu8U6Edy2qyGcI","audioLanguage":null,"audioDuration":3.186938775510204,"captionsUrl":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/captions/bAXB8ee4WGLlEIKZN7ORt.vtt","zoomPositionX":null,"zoomPositionY":null,"zoomWidth":null,"zoomHeight":null,"playbackRate":1,"mute":null,"mediaFitMode":"Cover","mediaAlignMode":"Top","htmlCaptureId":null,"backdrop":"None","pageUrl":"https://core.iqidis.ai/chat/cea66a5b-3f43-42f7-bb1b-f6839ae53e84","recordingSessionId":null,"preventScroll":false,"scrollTopOverride":null,"scrollOverrides":null,"duration":null,"transition":null,"customDescription":null,"hotspots":[{"id":"cmulqa7ib028lqmfhqkppok2f","number":9,"createdAt":"2026-09-28T20:56:56.195Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:36.428Z","default":true,"text":"The answer sets out the rules and the cases that apply.","bgcolor":"#6487d7","textcolor":"#ffffff","mouseXCooridnate":"31.768707482993197","mouseYCooridnate":"32.190132370637784","style":"Circle","animation":"Ping","isVisible":true,"boxWidth":null,"boxHeight":null,"prevslide":null,"nextslide":null,"stepId":"cmulqa7ib028kqmfhgb7s0p7z","tipposition":"right","nextButton":true,"textVisible":true,"htmlValue":"$26","aiText":null,"aiTextVisible":false,"anchorNodeId":null,"anchorPosition":"BottomCenter","nextButtonText":"Next","backButtonText":"Prev","hotspotWidth":"Medium","textAlign":"Left","modalPosition":"Center","borderRadius":"Round","nextButtonAction":"Slide","nextButtonUrl":null,"nextButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","nextButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","nextButtonDisabled":false,"backButtonAction":"Slide","backButtonUrl":null,"backButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","backButtonTextColor":null,"backButtonDisabled":false,"timelineElementId":null}],"chapter":null,"videoProject":null},{"id":"cmulqaay5028tqmfhyrci78p2","number":9,"text":null,"image":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/84rXHqBc31eMI9yaSbB98.jpg","video":null,"createdAt":"2026-09-28T20:57:00.653Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:59.323Z","demoId":"cmryqisu358m5qmblk0l574u5","imageWidth":"688","imageHeight":"0","mouseXCooridnate":"40.98639455782313","mouseYCooridnate":"59.02527075812274","editedImage":null,"widthOrg":2940,"heightOrg":1662,"bgcolor":"#4f46e5","textcolor":"#fff","imgState":null,"trimStart":0,"trimEnd":100,"videoWidth":null,"videoHeight":null,"videoDuration":null,"videoProjectId":null,"audio":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/audio/ABwgaVWl5P5zuQP1eyz9B.mp3","audioText":"Click a citation number to open the source.","voice":"FPQ1Odtu8U6Edy2qyGcI","audioLanguage":null,"audioDuration":2.168163265306122,"captionsUrl":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/captions/ABwgaVWl5P5zuQP1eyz9B.vtt","zoomPositionX":0.9863945578231323,"zoomPositionY":19.02527075812274,"zoomWidth":80,"zoomHeight":80,"playbackRate":1,"mute":null,"mediaFitMode":"Cover","mediaAlignMode":"Top","htmlCaptureId":null,"backdrop":"None","pageUrl":"https://core.iqidis.ai/chat/cea66a5b-3f43-42f7-bb1b-f6839ae53e84","recordingSessionId":null,"preventScroll":false,"scrollTopOverride":null,"scrollOverrides":null,"duration":null,"transition":null,"customDescription":null,"hotspots":[{"id":"cmulqaay5028uqmfh6dn7s284","number":10,"createdAt":"2026-09-28T20:57:00.653Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:36.617Z","default":true,"text":"Click a citation number to open the source.","bgcolor":"#6487d7","textcolor":"#ffffff","mouseXCooridnate":"40.98639455782313","mouseYCooridnate":"59.02527075812274","style":"Circle","animation":"Ping","isVisible":true,"boxWidth":null,"boxHeight":null,"prevslide":null,"nextslide":null,"stepId":"cmulqaay5028tqmfhyrci78p2","tipposition":"top","nextButton":true,"textVisible":true,"htmlValue":"$27","aiText":null,"aiTextVisible":false,"anchorNodeId":null,"anchorPosition":"BottomCenter","nextButtonText":"Next","backButtonText":"Prev","hotspotWidth":"Medium","textAlign":"Left","modalPosition":"Center","borderRadius":"Round","nextButtonAction":"Slide","nextButtonUrl":null,"nextButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","nextButtonTextColor":"#ffffff","nextButtonDisabled":false,"backButtonAction":"Slide","backButtonUrl":null,"backButtonBgColor":"#83a0da","backButtonTextColor":null,"backButtonDisabled":false,"timelineElementId":null}],"chapter":null,"videoProject":null},{"id":"cmulqagab0295qmfhvawv0ql7","number":10,"text":null,"image":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/NiIy0bsVABonfM6iJb4_t.jpg","video":null,"createdAt":"2026-09-28T20:57:07.571Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:59.323Z","demoId":"cmryqisu358m5qmblk0l574u5","imageWidth":"688","imageHeight":"0","mouseXCooridnate":"75.4421768707483","mouseYCooridnate":"54.87364620938629","editedImage":null,"widthOrg":2940,"heightOrg":1662,"bgcolor":"#4f46e5","textcolor":"#fff","imgState":null,"trimStart":0,"trimEnd":100,"videoWidth":null,"videoHeight":null,"videoDuration":null,"videoProjectId":null,"audio":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/audio/QfHgFfhInsHAPWhLmmPsy.mp3","audioText":"Case citations open the full opinion on CourtListener.","voice":"FPQ1Odtu8U6Edy2qyGcI","audioLanguage":null,"audioDuration":2.925714285714286,"captionsUrl":"https://media.supademo.com/cmpe0035s000kzu0jnzes3o1y/captions/QfHgFfhInsHAPWhLmmPsy.vtt","zoomPositionX":15,"zoomPositionY":12.37364620938629,"zoomWidth":85,"zoomHeight":85,"playbackRate":1,"mute":null,"mediaFitMode":"Cover","mediaAlignMode":"Top","htmlCaptureId":null,"backdrop":"None","pageUrl":"https://core.iqidis.ai/chat/cea66a5b-3f43-42f7-bb1b-f6839ae53e84","recordingSessionId":null,"preventScroll":false,"scrollTopOverride":null,"scrollOverrides":null,"duration":null,"transition":null,"customDescription":null,"hotspots":[{"id":"cmulqagab0296qmfhg2xver71","number":11,"createdAt":"2026-09-28T20:57:07.571Z","updatedAt":"2026-09-28T21:01:36.760Z","default":true,"text":"Case citations open the full opinion on CourtListener.","bgcolor":"#6487d7","textcolor":"#ffffff","mouseXCooridnate":"75.4421768707483","mouseYCooridnate":"54.87364620938629","style":"Circle","animation":"Ping","isVisible":true,"boxWidth":null,"boxHeight":null,"prevslide":null,"nextslide":null,"stepId":"cmulqagab0295qmfhvawv0ql7","tipposition":"left","nextButton":true,"textVisible":true,"htmlValue":"

Tracing the authorities

Verify New Mexico statutes

Find controlling New Mexico decisions

Synthesize the governing standard

Investigating

Verify New Mexico statutes

Find controlling New Mexico decisions

Synthesize the governing standard

Reasoning complete

Verify New Mexico statutes

Reasoning complete

Short Answer

Elements Against the Defendant

Potential Bases for Defendant Liability

1. Agency or Vicarious Liability

2. Retained-Control Liability

3. Defendant’s Own Direct Negligence

4. Nondelegable Duty

Effect of the Third-Party-Fault Defense

Practical Proof Required

Reasoning complete

New Mexico Standard

Potential Bases for Liability

1. Defendant’s Direct Negligence

2. Retained-Control Liability

3. Agency or Employee Status

4. Nondelegable Duty

Causation and Third-Party Fault

References

Sources & Citations